Tildown▶ Play

Dev blog ›

Rebuilding a gridlocked city, step by step

Our tips list the rules against traffic jams. Here we play them through once: on a town that makes the most common mistake, one change at a time, with the numbers the game shows afterwards. By the end, eleven times as many people live on the same 81 plots, and we did not add a single home.

A small Tildown town: a residential quarter of single-family homes in the north, shops and factories by the river in the south, and a single road full of cars between them
The starting point: homes in the north, jobs by the river, and exactly one road between them.

The experiment

For this post we founded a new city in a river valley in Tildown 1.3.1 and laid it out the way many first cities turn out: a residential quarter in the north, shops and factories down by the river, and a single road between them. Then we left it alone for an hour of play.

After that we only worked on roads and zoning, and watched for another half to three quarters of an hour after each change. We had filled the treasury for the experiment so that money would not distort anything. We still say what each step costs in the game.

A town that has stopped growing

Traffic view of the town: almost every road is turquoise, only the link between the residential quarter and the job district is amber and red at its end
The traffic view shows it at once: everything is clear except the few tiles everyone has to cross.

Before long nothing grew any more. 81 homes, 1,272 residents, and it stayed that way however long we waited. In the south, meanwhile, large commercial buildings had long since gone up, because at this size a jam does not yet hold shops and businesses back.

Every home names the reason itself. Tap one and the building panel says “Commute: ~21 tiles · jam”, below it “Bottleneck: road at 134%” with the distance, and under growth “waiting for clear roads”. The “📍 Show” button jumps to the spot. For all 81 homes it was the same tile: the junction where the link road leaves the quarter.

The traffic view shows the same thing from above. Almost everything is turquoise, which means clear. Only the few tiles that every commute crosses are red. An ordinary road tile carries 400 commuters, and from 100 percent load the homes behind it stop levelling up. We described how that calculation works in How commuters find their way.

Step 1: two more ways in

Traffic view after the change: three roads now link the residential quarter to the job district, and every road is turquoise
Six road tiles later: three ways in and out instead of one, and nothing is red any more.

The cheapest change first. On the left and right edges of the quarter, three tiles of road were missing on each side to reach the job district. Six tiles of ordinary road cost 48 💰 in total.

The effect was immediate: the highest load dropped from 134 to 60 percent, and no home was stuck in a jam any more. As a side effect the average commute became a good two tiles shorter, because homes at the edge no longer had to drive to the middle first.

The lesson is simple. A quarter with a single access sends every commuter across the same tile, no matter how many streets it has inside. The grid within the quarter was never the problem.

Half an hour later it is red again

Traffic view half an hour of play later: all three link roads are amber and red again
Half an hour later: the town has grown two and a half times over, and all three links are full.

Then came what always happens in Tildown when a jam disappears: the homes grew. After half an hour of play the town had 3,276 residents, a good two and a half times as many as before. Bigger homes send out more commuters, and so all 81 were stuck again, this time on three roads instead of one.

That is not a setback, it is the normal course of things. A jam in Tildown marks the place where the city is currently hitting its limit. Solve it and you get growth, and growth brings the next bottleneck. It never costs money, and it never downgrades anything.

Step 2: shops next to the quarter

The tips name proximity as the cheapest remedy: people who live close to work load only a few tiles. There was no room left inside the quarter, so we drew a road along its western edge and zoned commerce on both sides. Zoning is free.

The result was, frankly, thin. Nine businesses appeared and the town grew to 4,136 residents, but 77 of 81 homes were still stuck. A narrow strip at the edge offers work to only a few, and for most homes it is no closer than the south. Proximity works when commerce sits between the residential blocks from the start. Stuck onto the edge afterwards, it only helps the neighbours.

The step was useful in one way all the same: from 3,500 residents the game unlocks the main road.

Step 3: main road, but only on the red tiles

Traffic view after the first upgrade to main roads: the upgraded axes are clear, and short stretches at their ends are now red
After the first upgrade: the main roads are clear, and the jam now sits where they end.

A main road carries eight times as many commuters as an ordinary road and counts only half towards the commute. In return it is expensive, and its price grows with the city: in our experiment one tile cost 21,436 💰. So we did not upgrade whole axes, only the tiles that were red in the traffic view. There were 24 of them, 514,464 💰 in total.

Right afterwards only 18 homes were still stuck. Three quarters of an hour later the town had 5,532 residents, and it was 72 again. The bottleneck now stood at 170 percent on an ordinary road tile, directly beyond the end of the new main road.

That is the second lesson. A main road attracts traffic because it shortens the route on paper, and at its end it hands that traffic to the next ordinary road. The jam does not vanish, it moves on a little.

Building after the jam

Traffic view at the end of the rebuild: the whole road network is turquoise, with only three short amber stretches
After the fourth upgrade: 50 tiles of main road, and not a single home is stuck in a jam.

From here on it was routine. Open the traffic view, upgrade the red tiles, watch. The second time it was eight tiles, the third and fourth time nine each. Every time the number of homes in a jam dropped to zero, and every time the town kept growing afterwards: to 9,884, to 12,248 and finally to 14,372 residents.

You can see clearly how the jam travels. First it sat at the exits of the quarter, then it crept north along the three axes, three tiles further into the quarter each time. In all we upgraded 50 tiles for 1,071,800 💰. The other 281 road tiles of the city stayed ordinary roads.

Where it ends up

The same town after the rebuild: the single-family homes have become dense blocks and residential towers
The same 81 plots a good four hours of play later: 14,372 residents instead of 1,272.

A good four hours of play after the first change, 14,372 people live on the same 81 plots instead of 1,272. The average commute has fallen from 18 to just over 9 tiles, because a main road counts only half. The village-era cottages have become blocks and the first residential towers.

That does not make the city finished. At the end of our experiment 28 homes were stuck again, at 123 percent. And at some point even a main road is full. Then other tools help: one-way streets in pairs, a car park, later rail and metro. When each of them pays off is covered in Avoiding traffic jams: road networks that flow.

In short

If you would like to try it yourself: the guide explains the tools, and a new city is founded in a few seconds.

All posts →

Build a city yourself – free in your browser, no download.

▶ Play now