Tildown▶ Play

Tips & strategies ›

Residential, commercial, industry: keeping the balance

Five homes, two shops, one factory, all at level 5: seven people are out of work and housing grows at barely 9% of full speed. The Demand card also tells you why: “hardly in demand (no spare jobs)”. Your city grows only as fast as its three sectors carry each other, and it only gets fast with a surplus.

Tildown: the Demand card is open and shows what residential, commercial and industry need right now; behind it a riverside city with residential towers, factories and bridges.

What each sector offers and needs

The basic rule is in the guide; the interesting part is what follows from it. Every connected building levels up as fast as the demand for its sector in its own road network allows. Neither jams nor commutes slow commerce and industry down; homes also need clean air, short commutes and free-flowing roads (more on that). And every level shifts the balance. If the bars swing out again after a growth spurt, that’s just the normal rhythm.

In a young city you’ll notice something. Once shops and goods are just covered at the same level, jobs are still missing, because five homes bring more workers than two shops and a factory can employ. As the city grows, so do expectations: per head it gradually needs up to 30% more shops; half of that is reached at 5,000 residents. The goods each shop needs stay the same. Two landmarks help with this. With the Sydney Opera House, per head it needs only up to 12% more shops (6% once upgraded, 0% fully upgraded), and the Pyramids of Giza balance up to 20% of the city’s goods demand – they bring missing goods and take surplus ones away.

What sits behind the demand bars

The 🏠 · 🏢 · 🏭 bars compare three balances: jobs against workers, shops against need, goods against need. Each sector lives on two of them: residential needs spare jobs and shops, commercial customers and goods, industry spare workers and buyers. If goods and workers are short at the same time, the industry bar can still point left, with the reason “no spare workers”; the tooltip then says: residential first, then industry. Goods simply only come from factories, and factories only grow with people.

The bars show ratios, not amounts: a gap of 10% weighs the same with 1,000 residents as with 100,000. Tap the card and it gives you the balance in figures, such as “Balance: jobs 35/42 · shops 30/30 · goods 20/18”, plus speed and reason for each sector, such as “hardly in demand (no spare jobs)”. It’s worth it: that is where you see what is missing before you build.

And “balanced” doesn’t mean “fast”. With every balance exactly covered, your buildings grow at only a little over a third of full speed. Parks give housing a boost but never replace a surplus. If your city is treading water, the card tells you itself with “Balanced means slow”, along with the current speed.

An example in numbers

Five homes, two shops and one factory, all at level 5, on one shared road, no parks: the balance reads jobs 35/42 – seven people are out of work, and housing demand reaches barely 9% of full speed. The Demand card reports “hardly in demand (no spare jobs)” for residential, but “in demand” for commercial and industry, at 50 and 57% speed: both bring jobs.

A single new shop at level 1 lifts housing speed from 9 to around 32%; a new factory only to around 15%. The shop creates jobs and places to shop at the same time, so it feeds both ingredients of housing demand at once. The button below the card offers you the sector most in demand, here “Zone Industry”, because industry itself grows fastest. Both create jobs; for housing, the shop is the stronger lever.

What an imbalance costs

Too much housing costs you twice. Every unemployed resident costs 0.6 💰 of welfare per second, so 100 unemployed cost 60 💰 per second. You’ll find the amount in the income tooltip under “− Welfare”. On top of that, your homes pay less tax, because missing work weighs more heavily for them than missing shops; the 📈 value on the Money card shows this.

Too much commerce or industry is cheaper. Open jobs cost no welfare, but shops and factories without staff pay less, and so do shops without customers and factories whose goods nobody buys. The Supply card shows this in blue as soon as shops or goods exceed 115% of need. Tap a building: under “Needs (coverage)” you’ll see what’s missing, and for commerce and industry the “Jobs” line tells you how many are staffed.

You can’t lose anything this way. No building stands empty or shrinks for lack of jobs, and your net income never drops below zero. An imbalance only slows you down. Once upkeep and welfare together reach your taxes, the Money card warns you with “⚠️ Upkeep”. That’s your signal to create jobs.

Shops belong among the homes

A home’s commute leads to the nearest shop or factory in the same road network, as long as it has jobs free. If all of them are taken, the commuters drive up to 12 tiles further. Up to ten tiles the commute costs nothing (within the Little Mermaid’s radius up to 14). Beyond that, every tile lowers the home’s taxes, its growth speed and the workforce that actually reaches shops and factories, down to 55% at 40 tiles.

So don’t bundle commerce into a distant shopping district; scatter it in small groups between the housing blocks. A shop on a residential street shortens the commute of the homes around it, as far as its jobs go, and it benefits too: homes and other shops nearby raise its location, worth up to +25% tax.

Industry, on the other hand, likes its own kind, and other factories around it raise its location. Its smog mostly hurts homes; ordinary shops don’t mind it. A strip of commerce between factories and homes therefore creates distance and still counts as a workplace. How wide it should be is covered in the tip on beautiful neighbourhoods, and why the routes must still stay short in the tip on avoiding traffic jams.

Reading the four cards at the top

For a single building, the panel names the brake under “Growth”, e.g. “growing slowly – no spare jobs”. For the whole city at once, the “🌱 Growth” view in the 🗺️ menu shows the same thing: it colours every building by its brake. Red needs below 80% can be tapped and pick the right tool.

When adjusting, zone new land for the missing sector instead of rezoning grown buildings. Zoning is free, rezoning is not, and what else it costs is listed under typical beginner mistakes.

For high speed, keep one sector a little ahead. With around 30% more jobs than workers in the balance, 13 in the example above, and shops covered, housing grows at full speed, given clean air, short commutes and free-flowing roads. The newcomers fill the jobs, then shops or goods run short, and the next sector is up.

Try it right away – free in your browser, no download.

▶ Play now